Climate Money Watchdog
  • Blog
  • Who We Are
  • Get In Touch
  • DONATE
  • Podcast Directory Listings
  • Blog
  • Who We Are
  • Get In Touch
  • DONATE
  • Podcast Directory Listings
Non-Partisan, Non-Profit

Climate Money Watchdog

Lew Daly - 45Q Carbon Capture Tax Credits are a Financial Disaster in the Making

5/1/2025

 
Picture
  • Our guest tonight is Lew Daly, Senior Fellow for Climate and Energy Policy at Just Solutions, where he works in partnership with state and federal organizations and networks in pursuit of a just and equitable clean energy transition. 

His previous 15 years work in the public policy field includes appointments such as:

​
  • Director of Policy and Research and Senior Policy Analyst for Climate Equity at Demos
  • Deputy Director of Climate Policy at the Roosevelt Institute 
Lew is a lifelong resident of New York State--Born and raised in Onondaga County, Central New York State, and has been based with his family in Wester Harlem, New York City, since 1999. His New York service in the field includes:
  • Steering Committee member of the New York Renews Coalition from 2017-2020.
  • Co-coordinator: New York Renews Policy Development Committee, supporting the development and passage of the nation-leading Climate Leadership and Community Protection act in 2019.
  • Member of the New York City Offshore Wind Advisory Council in 2022 and 2023.
He has also worked internationally as a US member of the Global Well-Being Lab of the Presencing Institute and Germany's Global Leadership Academy, and as an International Advisory Board Member of the Centre for the Study of Governance Innovation at the University of Pretoria.
With Doug Koplow of Earth Track, Lew is the author most recently of the report, Taxpayer Costs for Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage, just out from Just Solutions and Earth Track. 
In addition to his extensive policy work, Lew's commentaries and feature articles have appeared in the New York Times, the Washington Post, the New Republic, Democracy Journal, Boston Review, Grist, and many other publications. 
Support the show

Natural Gas is Worse than Coal - Dr. Robert Howarth

3/10/2025

 
Picture
​While the fossil fuel industry continues to promote "natural gas" as a relatively "clean" energy source, Dr. Robert Howarth has argued since since his seminal report in 2011 that methane (which makes up roughly 5% of "natural gas") poses a greater threat to humankind than "dirty" options like coal and oil. This is particularly true of methane produced through hydraulic fracturing ("fracking") Join us for a conversation about what we've now known for more than a decade, and how much more convinced Dr. Howarth is now that we should not be fracking for gas, nor otherwise be using methane as an energy source.
Dr. Howarth is the David R. Atkinson Professor of Ecology & Environmental Biology in the Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology at Cornell University. He’s an Earth systems scientist, ecosystem biologist, and biogeochemist. He has worked extensively on environmental issues related to human-induced changes in the sulfur, nitrogen, phosphorus, and carbon cycles, the impacts of global climate change, the interaction of energy systems and the environment, and implementation of 100% renewable energy policies. He is the Founding Editor of the journal Biogeochemistry.
Currently, Howarth serves as one of 22 members of the Climate Action Council, the group charged by law with implementing the aggressive climate goals of New York’s Climate Leadership & Community Protection Act of 2019, often referred to as CLCPA. Howarth has published more than 200 research papers, and these have been cited in other peer-reviewed articles more than 70,000 times, making Howarth one of the ten most cited aquatic scientists in the world. In 2011, Time Magazine named Howarth as one of 50 “People Who Matter” for his research on the greenhouse gas footprint of shale gas produced from hydraulic fracturing, better known as “fracking”.
Topics Discussed Include:
  • Why methane is such a concern with regard to climate change
  • Why methane emissions are greater than predicted by the gas industry
  • Why Dr. Howarth believes methane is worse for the climate than coal
  • How some methane leaks are accidental while others are routine, and therefore can't be eliminated
  • How OGI thermal cameras are able to see methane and other greenhouse gasses
Further Reading
Dr. Howarth maintains a web site featuring many of the works he's published over the years, including the April 2011 paper on methane leaks from gas fracking.

A Law Firm Just for Whistleblowers - Poppy Alexander

6/11/2024

 
Picture
​We’re delighted to welcome back Poppy Alexander, a founding partner at the law firm Whistleblower Partners, a law firm dedicated to representing whistleblowers reporting fraud and misconduct in:
  • Healthcare
  • Procurement
  • Securities and Commodities
  • Taxes
  • Money Laundering and Sanctions Evasion
  • Customs
  • Environmental Remediation
  • Vehicle Safety

Poppy represents whistleblowers and government entities in qui tam lawsuits, as well as under the various agency whistleblower programs including those administered by the Internal Revenue Service, Securities and Exchange Commission, FinCEN, Commodity Futures Trading Commission, and Department of Transportation.  Poppy’s practice focuses on issues of international corruption and financial misconduct, with a specialty in the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and money laundering cases.  She writes and speaks regularly about emerging topics in financial fraud, including sanctions violations, SPACs, and cryptocurrency.
​
We last spoke with Poppy back in July of 2022 when she had already established an impressive track record representing whistleblowers at Constantine Cannon. She graduated from Harvard Law School in 2012. She was the co-editor-in-chief of the Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review and an active participant in the Human Rights Clinic, working on issues related to corporate accountability for human rights violations in Africa and military abuses in Southeast Asia. She was awarded the Dean’s Award for Community Leadership in recognition for her contributions to the school community. Poppy has been named to the Super Lawyers Rising Stars list every year since 2016. Prior to law school, Poppy worked on election reform issues before beginning graduate work at the University of California, Berkeley, where she studied political and critical theory.

We’ve invited Poppy to talk about her new work, and her new firm, Whisteblower Partners.
​
Topics Discussed Include:
  • Poppy’s new law firm, Whistleblower Partners. Why Poppy left her old firm to establish this new legal partnership in March 2024.  She describes a comprehensive approach to whistleblowers and not just file cases.
  • The laws Whistleblower Partners uses in environmental cases and how they have changed since the episode we published in July 2023. Qui tam False Claims Act, SEC, IRS, Act to Prevent Pollution from Ships (APPS), and various wildlife protection laws.
  • Examples of Whistleblower Partners victories.
  • Pitfalls of whistleblowing and filing lawsuits and administrative tips programs.
 
Further Reading / Topics Discussed in this Episode:
  • Mighty Earth  vs. JBS in protecting the Brazilian rainforest
  • The Securities and Exchange Commission’s 90th birthday
  • The Department of Justice policy sprint for whistleblowers
  • qui tam lawsuits
  • ​whistleblower programs
  • Internal Revenue Service
  • Securities and Exchange Commission
  • FinCEN
  • Commodity Futures Trading Commission
  •  Department of Transportation:

How The Plastics Industry is Tied to Fossil Fuels – Melissa Valliant

3/21/2024

 
Picture
We’re pleased to have as our guest Melissa Valliant, Director of Communications for Beyond Plastics, a non-profit organization dedicated to ending plastic polution. She grew up on the Eastern Shore of Maryland and graduated from Syracuse University with a plan to pursue magazine journalism. Somewhere along the way, she became hooked on environmental conservation and discovered a love for leveraging her communications abilities to make the world a better place. Melissa had her first letter to the editor published in a kids' science magazine at the age of 11 and has since been published in the New York Times, Washington Post, Wall Street Journal, and USA Today, among others. Prior to her role at Beyond Plastics, she managed communications for Oceana's plastics campaign and worked for the National Aquarium in Baltimore.
​
Topics Discussed Include:
  • How environmental and health problems are connected with micro plastic and nano plastic particles and why scientists are alarmed.
  • Why only 9 percent of plastic waste recycled.
  • How the plastics lobby/greenwashing industries that were against abatement and reform.
  • How the Fossil Fuel believes they can make up for future oil market loss with plastics production.
  • How plastic manufacturing is highly polluting, where in the country we produce it, and impacts on local communities.
  • What is currently being done to reform and what ultimately needs to be done to start to fix the problem.
Further Reading / Topics Discussed in this Episode:
  • Consider the positive and aspects of “The crying Indian” commercial on American society.
  • How do prominent projects such as “Mr. Trash Wheel” encourage plastics removal/recycling versus reduction of plastics production affect public perception?
  • Media Briefing on Polution in Port Arthur, TX
  • Break Free from Plastic Pollution Act
  • The Packaging Reduction and Recycling Infrastructure Act
  • Beyond Plastics Affiliates
  • Beyond Plastics petitions

How Fossil Fuel Subsidies Affect the Environment - Doug Koplow

2/29/2024

 
Picture
Doug founded Earth Track to more effectively integrate information on energy subsidies. For the past three decades, he has written extensively on natural resource subsidies for organizations such as the International Institute for Sustainable Development, the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), Sierra Club, the Natural Resources Defense Council, and the Stockholm Environment Institute.  He has analyzed scores of government programs and made important developments in subsidy valuation techniques.  He has provided input on subsidy reform legislation, served as a peer reviewer on subsidy papers from all over the world, and has published his own work in major journals and as book chapters.  In recent years, his work has focused on subsidies to fossil fuels, nuclear power, and the impact of multi-sector natural resource subsidies on biodiversity and critical habitats.

​Working collaboratively with other organizations, Earth Track focuses on ways to more effectively align the incentives of key stakeholder groups and to leverage market forces to help address complex environmental challenges.
 
He holds an MBA from the Harvard Business School and a BA in economics from Wesleyan University.

Topics Discussed Include:
  • Government subsidies - why they are important to think about as we try to decarbonize our economy. 
  • How oil and gas subsides work in general and why they are outdated and harmful to climate goals.
  • How taxpayers’ subsidies distort the market for oil and gas produced in Permian Basin.
  • The role of different levels of government in supporting oil and gas and whether there are specific challenges trying to reform state-level policies.
  • How some subsides were passed in the 1920s when oil extraction was a new industry and haven’t been changed to match the times.
  • How three quarters of the subsides support exploration and production, potentially creating a disincentive to phasing out fossil fuel energy.
  • How transparency of information on costs and how is paid is often lacking
  • Particularly egregious subsidies in the federal realm, in Texas, and New Mexico.
  • Examples of federal and state regulations and environmental exemptions that allow the fossil fuel production pollution to walk away from their production pollution and how that is affecting the Permian Basin’s environment for the people.
Further Reading: 
  • The High Cost Well subsidy
  • The Good Jobs First organization

Developing Clean Energy Solutions for the Seneca Nation - Matt Renner

2/1/2024

 
Picture
Matt Renner serves as Vice President of Seneca Environmental, a tribally owned and controlled Earth-healing solutions company focused on helping commercial customers achieve ambitious climate goals while supporting the long-term well-being of the Seneca Nation and other Indigenous people. His work focuses on partnership development and customer acquisition to create unprecedented collaboration and profitably accelerate climate action. 
Matt has worked as a nonprofit executive in clean energy, climate policy, and journalism for over a decade, focusing on the near-term social and economic impacts of climate change. He was the head of Climate Mobilization and now serves on their board of directors. He began his career as an investigative reporter and later became the Executive Director of the World Business Academy to focus on the transition to a climate-constrained economic paradigm.
Matt has a BA degree in Political Science and Government from the University of California, Berkeley. 
Topics Discussed Include:
  • How Seneca Environmental is set up and its main goals.
  • Why the Seneca Nation set up a specific section to invest in clean climate change solutions.
  • How Seneca Environmental made the 2023 Time100 List and what Matt has done to make Seneca Environmental unique.
  • An outline of the work Renner has done for the Native American community and for corporate businesses on producing clean energy.
  • Why Seneca Environmental’s business model is working for both the Native American community and corporate businesses.
  • How Seneca Environmental’s model and efforts can be replicated with other tribes and businesses to help the clean energy movement going forward.
Further Reading:
  • The Seneca Environmental web site
  • Video overview of the Seneca Nation
  • Federal Tax Credits for Businesses
  • Department of Energy Loan Programs

Problems with Q45 Tax Credits for Carbon – Paul Blackburn

1/25/2024

 
Picture
Our guest tonight is Paul Blackburn of Pipeline Fighters’ Hub. Paul provides legal services on pipeline and renewable energy matters. He has worked on crude oil pipeline issues since 2008, and has experience in renewable energy policy and development. Paul represented nonprofit clients in the South Dakota Public Utilities Commission hearing on the Keystone XL Pipeline, and in the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission hearing on expansion of Line 67, another Enbridge pipeline. He has provided policy analysis and strategic advice on a variety of pipeline matters and authored reports on pipeline safety and oil spill response.
Paul started his legal career in Washington, DC, at the law firm of Van Ness Feldman, where he assisted clients in renewable energy and coal-fired power plant development, a variety of regulatory, legislative, and litigation matters, and Native American commercial law.  After leaving private practice, he began a career in the nonprofit sector, including employment by the Sierra Club, the National Environmental Trust, and Oceana in organizing and media.  He also has experience in community wind and solar energy development.  Paul holds a B.A. in Biology from Macalester College and a J.D. from Boston College Law School.
In this episode we discuss topics including:
  • An overview of the Q45 Carbon sequestration tax credit program
  • Who benefits from the Q45 Tax Credit Program?
  • How Fossil Fuel companies take advantage of the Q45 program and use it to continue to justify producing more fossil fuel
  • Problems with the reporting system for 45Q to the EPA and IRS
For more information, see:
  • The Pipeline Fighters Hub web site
  • The Congressional Research Service’s page on the Q45 program

Standing Up for Communities in Houston – Erandi Trevino

8/23/2023

 
Picture
Our guest this episode is Erandi Trevino of Public Citizen, Houston. Erandi grew up in Houston and has been concerned about the pollution in her neighborhood since she was a young child.
Before joining Public Citizen in Houston as a Climate Policy and Outreach Specialist, she was an Advocacy Fellow with the Fulbright Association in Washington, DC, where she worked on education policy, nutrition, and financial regulations. During her time in DC, Erandi also volunteered for the Congressional Hispanic Caucus Institute.
Earlier in her career, Erandi assisted the Permanent Representative of Mexico to the United Nations in New York. She has a law degree from Fordham University and degrees in International Relations and Latin American studies from Seton Hall University. Following her graduation there, she received a Fulbright Grant to teach English in Belo Horizonte, Brazil where she became fluent in Portuguese.
In this episode we discuss the following topics:
  • The coalition of companies and other institutions that are partners with this new project called the HyVelocity Hub and their claims to be able to build an “ecosystem” from the existing hydrogen and pipeline industry in Houston to make clean hydrogen.
  • HyVelocity Hub claims that they will be able use carbon capture to make “clean” hydrogen (called blue hydrogen) using existing hydrogen production plants.
  • How credible is Houston’s Clean Hydrogen Roadmap in general?
  • Is HyVelocity’s goal of achieving 2kg CO2 / kg of H2 is realistic?
  • RMI currently estimates 20 kg CO2 / kg H2 with Texas’s current fossil-heavy power grid.
  • How credible is HyVelocity’s vision “to serve disadvantaged communities by providing jobs and higher labor standards, reducing local pollution, and supporting and complying with the Justice40 initiative?
  • Who are the powerful investors in this endeavor and how are they affecting the plans for these plants? Are they listening to local concerns or just greenwashing their environmental challenges?
  • What is Public Citizen doing as a local activist to get some oversight on this HyVelocity Hub project?
Resources:
Center for Houston's Future
Houston Healthy Port Communities Coalition
Environmental Defense Fund - Better Hubs - Expring Decarbonizing Industry
Greater Houston Port Bureau's Project 11
On Breath Partnership's "What is Port Houston's Project 11?" 
Erandi's Contact Information
Support the show

Reducing Carbon Dioxide by 27% in Indiana - David Konisky

8/6/2023

 
Picture
Our guest, Dr. David Konisky is a Lynton K. Caldwell Professor with the Paul H. O’Neill School of Public and Environmental Affairs at Indiana University, whose research focuses on U.S. environmental policy and politics, with particular emphasis on environmental and energy justice, regulation, federalism, and public opinion.

David came to our attention through a PBS interview in which he described Indiana industries reducing their greenhouse gas emissions by an impressive 27% over the last decade, largely without a state organized campaign or incentives.

He has authored or edited six books on environmental politics and policy, including Fifty Years at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency: Progress, Retrenchment and Opportunities (Rowman & Littlefield, 2020, with Jim Barnes and John  D. Graham), Failed Promises: Evaluating the Federal Government's Response to Environmental Justice (MIT Press, 2015), and Cheap and Clean: How Americans Think about Energy in the Age of Global Warming (MIT Press, 2014, with Steve Ansolabehere). He has been the co-editor of the journal Environmental Politics since the beginning of 2021. 

Konisky’s research has been funded by the National Science Foundation, the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, the U.S. Department of Energy, and the Russell Sage Foundation.
Konisky earned his Ph.D. in political science from MIT. He also holds two master’s degrees from Yale University: one in environmental management and one in international relations. At the undergraduate level, he studied history and environmental studies at Washington University in St. Louis.
​
Topics we discuss include:

  • Indiana’s greenhouse gases emissions are down largely due to substituting gas power generation for coal, with six more coal-fired plants scheduled to close by 2028. Without a concerted government effort, what caused this to happen? Market forces? Local advocacy? Something else?
  • While the gas-fired plants replacing the coal-fired ones emit less carbon dioxide (CO2), they still emit some CO2, and the gas pipelines that feed them can also leak methane gas which is a more potent greenhouse gas than CO2. Is the transition to gas helpful to the climate, or is slowing the transition bad for the climate?
  • How much resistance is there in the state and local governments in Indiana to transition to clean energy? Who is causing this resistance?
  • Will the Biden Administration’s Justice 40 initiative be effective in addressing economic and environmental justice issues? Can efforts such as these be effective in both rural and urban communities?

How Today’s Technology Can Save Our Climate and Clean Our Air: Mark Z. Jacobson

7/13/2023

 
Picture
We’re excited to welcome back Mark Z. Jacobson, who joined us last year to talk about a study he co-authored called “Low-Cost Solutions to Global Warming, Air Pollution, and Energy Insecurity for 145 Countries”. He is a professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering and Director of the Atmosphere/Energy program at Stanford University, as well as a Senior Fellow at the Woods Institute for the Environment and Precourt Institute for energy, and also the Co-Founder of The Solutions Project, 100.org and the 100% Clean, Renewable Energy movement.

We've asked Mark back to see what progress the country has made with his prediction that the US and the world can change to clean energy and meet CO2 goals by only using WWS (wind, water and solar) i.e. clean non burning energy without using coal, gas, nuclear, and carbon capture. Mark released a book in February of this year, entitled No Miracles Needed: How Today’s Technology Can Save Our Climate and Clean Our Air. His book brings up more questions about the government and the some climate experts are promoting, such as carbon capture, instead of considering the potential of just using WWS. 

Topics covered include:

  • How does the time taken to construct different types of power plants effect their impact  in light of the short timetable on lowering CO2 and other greenhouse gases pollution?
  • How does the amount of waste heat  released by fossil fuel compare to that released by renewables? For example,  about 65 to 67 percent of energy in oil and coal is released as waste heat, 40 to 60 percent of natural gas energy is also waste heat, 74 percent of biomass is waste heat and 65 percent of the energy in uranium is waste heat.
  • According to Jacobson, “By 2021, the cost of a system consisting of wind, solar, and batteries was already less than that consisting of natural gas. For example, even in 2019, a Florida utility replaced two natural gas plants with a combined solar-battery system because of the lower cost of the later.” How do economics affect transition to renewable energy sources? 
  • What are the best and quickest energy source for commercial and military planes and cargo ships?
  • Is the U.S. grid ready for 100 percent clean electricity?
  • What has been the reaction to Jacobson's proposed  WWS solution?
Support the show

<<Previous

    Authors

    Dina Rasor
    ​Greg Williams

    ​

    Archives

    June 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    August 2023
    July 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    December 2021
    June 2021

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

© 2021 Climate Money Watchdog Inc., a Project of the Media Alliance, a tax-exempt 501(c)(3) Charitable Organization